Season Story Calculation is Flawed
Your Season Story grade is fundamentally flawed. I agree with including the in-season management and final results but by incorporating our draft score you're incorporating YOUR projection of our draft score. In one of my drafts, I drafted Kareem Hunt in the 4th round. Your draft analysis ridiculed me for this pick.
After Hunt finishing 3rd in overall running backs, I'd say I had the better draft strategy. I'd suggest if you do this again next year, you re-score the draft based on the final results and not on your questionable pre-draft rankings or even ADP.
Yeah, Yahoo's draft grades are often a joke.
It's tough to take them seriously when they are so frequently wrong.
It's also a savvy strategy to not bother drafting a Kicker, you pick up an extra bench guy instead and see how the depth charts shake out in the preseason. Maybe a rookie or something wins a starting job, or a starter gets hurt, and you've got yourself a lottery ticket that just hit big. But you get penalized in their grades for doing this.