Defense/Special teams lose points for lost/muffed kick/punt returns
Defense/Special teams should lose points for lost/muffed kick and punt returns. If the kicking team can gain points for recovering a muffed kickoff/punt, the receiving team should be penalized for losing said muffed kick/punt.
Jeff Cross commented
I was posting this exact same thing! I almost lost a game tonight because my WR fumbled the football on a punt return, but if that same player were to run it back for a touchdown, he would be awarded no points. Makes no sense.
Bernhard Hall commented
Stop giving kick/punt returners negative points for fumbles when their positive yards and touchdowns are credited to the DST. It’s all or nothing. It just doesn’t make sense.
Please make an option to give individual players ALL (good and bad) special teams points, or NOTHING.
The player who muffs the kick is charged with a fumble in the Yahoo! game, but not the D/ST.