The "My Yahoo" experience across all of the people complaining is different from person to person. Not just the 'suggestions' but the layout and the readability. Not to mention customized content for sports and stocks that cannot be done without entirely giving us My Yahoo back with all of those functions. Why go generic? Can't this old code base be maintained cheaply? How buggy and expensive is it after being stable for 20+ years? You need to listen to the community of users and not to some odd voice in your heads.