POSITION LIMITS PLEASE
PLEASE CREATE POSITION LIMITS FOR ROSTERS
Michael Haugan commented
This is a must! ESPN does this and is a basic feature that the commish should be able to enforce. For example, some teams hord QBs and/or RBs. Shouldn't be allowed.
billy bates commented
This is a must. People horde players, especially RB, and it’s crazy. I don’t think it’s strategy to stock pile players. Strategy is mixing and matching players based off bye weeks and matchups. In my league of 12, I’ve had the bench set at 5 for an 12 player rostered team. That’s the only way I can stop the hoarding. It still is difficult.
Ken McNulty commented
Yahoo needs to do this. I wouldn't change anything like this mid-season, but we have a yearly league that needs this at least for our 2021 season. We do 1QB and 1Superflex position. In the draft we have people drafting and hoarding 5-7 QB's. ESPN offers this level of customization, Yahoo needs to do something to try to keep up. You're falling WAY behind Yahoo!!!
Tom Kirk commented
BIG MUST HAVE!!! Too many people (the uneducated or nefarious ones) horde RBs during the season. Please ad feature. But allow Commissioners to set the limit.
If Yahoo implements this rule
and a commish changes to the rule after the draft,
will I be allowed to drop the league?
If not, then please don't allow this rule.
Brendan Salk commented
PLEASE! My league is 2 QB with 12 people. Need a limit of 3 QBs per roster. I have had to enforce this rule myself and have nearly gotten into 2 fights over it!
YES, DO THIS!!
Jonathan Zegadlo commented
do you mean benches specifically for offense and defense? id like that
Jon Medlinsky commented
Jim Pothast commented
Jeff Hussain I challenge you to try it!
Maybe you haven't played in free internet leagues much.
I have for over 20 years & they are a joke.
No one in the area will invite me to play locally because they know I have played for so long & they prefer to enjoy easy prey. How much fun is that? And that I want a fair league.
I just want to point out a few things. All also depends on the number of teams in the league.
There are always 2-3 that don't play at all. 2-3 that will submit a partial line up which is not playing.
There are always lousy commissioners. That don't know how to handle those who don't play.
How can you tell if your league is worth a ****?
Actual points scored vs max possible points. You should be above 80%.
Hoarders scores are usually lower because they have too much to choose from.
So really you hurt yourself.
Go back & max points the schedule would your record be the same? This is very interesting.
How would your league turn out if you were ALL perfect.
I am filling in in a league where there are hoarders the free agent pool is EMPTY & there was a guy who did not field half of his starting offense cause they were all on byes.WHAT FUN IS THAT?
If you are going to hoard at least pick the highest scoring person at that position each week or you are wasting your time.
It's a 20 team league (which are a complete joke) No more than 16 EVER!
If you are unable to fill your line up each week your league is a joke.
Nearly every league I played in I would run into an incomplete line up. Or the guy with a player who should definately be starting on the bench.
If you do not draft appropriately you shouldn't be playing. But in a 20 team league the are not enough QB's so why?
I've played in a league where the last place team did not play all season but did the week I played them & beat me costing a playoff spot. If they played all year I would have likely been in.
Fantasy should mirror the real thing. Granted there are teams with 3 RB & teams with 5.
There are still only 32 RB worth drafting.
Just try it once & compare it to the other league you are playing in.
If you read my other comment I have 4 other who play no other leagues now because of the competitiveness of this kind of league.
Jim Pothast commented
Hoarders kill leagues plain & simple.
A hoarder = a person not playing.
If you enjoy playing in a league where each team does not field a complete line up you are wasting your time & your (free) league is a joke.
You will all hate what I say UNTIL you try it.
I made a league with basic starters 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DEF with 1 bench player at each position at all times. 10 team league.
I get "it's to restrictive" all the time but there are more free agents than in a league the same people will play in. So how that is restrictive is beyond me.
Why my other owners like it:
Full line ups each week
a competitive game each week
a competitive league to where all teams are in it until the final week (too much parody for most)
and that is what it is all about a competitive league.
Granted this is primarily an internet league problem not so much with a local league where everyone knows everyone.
I do have openings in my league if interested. (Courtland Lee)
If I join a league and then the Commish imposes this limit rule,
will I be allowed to drop the league?
In the past, when the Commish changes rules,
Yahoo has not allowed us to drop out of the league.
I think this is a NEEDED option for the Commish to utilize (whether in private or public leagues). It is better to have it and need it,than not have it. So if this functionality becomes available, if you choose not to use, then that's fine for that league.
I would hate to join a league and then have the Commish put in a rule which limits how many players I can have in each position.
It's not necessary. It's not needed. It's not helpful.
The most likely players to get injured are RBs.
So, of course, you benefit from drafting a couple extra RBs.
I want to keep that ability.
I don't want to see leagues in which managers are limited to too few RBs.
Ignacio De La Torre commented
Can you put a max on the number of players at a position, e.g. max 4 RBs?
Alex Merza commented
Option should be added for commissioners in private leagues.
Bob Mesick commented
Make position limits available at the team level. I am in a league that is totally auto-draft and getting 5 RBs, 3 WRs and 2 DST just doesn't cut it.
Jason Cropper commented
This should remain in control of the commissioner. Our league doesn't want position limits.
Jeff Hussain commented
Why would you want position limits?